What If... of Hershey Info
Amenities
From the business
-
Identifies as women-owned
Service options
-
Outdoor seating
-
Curbside pickup
-
Delivery
-
Takeout
-
Dine-in
Highlights
-
Great dessert
Popular for
-
Dinner
-
Solo dining
Accessibility
-
Wheelchair accessible entrance
-
Wheelchair accessible parking lot
-
Wheelchair accessible restroom
-
Wheelchair accessible seating
Offerings
-
Alcohol
-
Beer
-
Cocktails
-
Coffee
-
Comfort food
-
Happy hour drinks
-
Happy hour food
-
Hard liquor
-
Healthy options
-
Late-night food
-
Small plates
-
Wine
Dining options
-
Dinner
-
Catering
-
Dessert
-
Seating
Amenities
-
Bar onsite
-
Restroom
-
Wi-Fi
Atmosphere
-
Casual
-
Cozy
-
Romantic
-
Trendy
-
Upscale
Crowd
-
Groups
-
Tourists
Planning
-
Dinner reservations recommended
-
Accepts reservations
Payments
-
Credit cards
-
Debit cards
-
NFC mobile payments
Children
-
Good for kids
-
High chairs
-
Kids' menu
Parking
-
Free parking lot
-
Free street parking
-
Parking
Other
-
Identifies as women-owned
Best WLM Reviews
My experience at What If of Hershey was nothing short of extraordinary. From the moment I walked in, I was blown away by the atmosphere and the impeccable service. Our server, Alec, was from another planet—his attentiveness and warmth made the entire evening unforgettable.
The food was unbelievably delicious, each dish bursting with flavor and cooked to perfection. The drinks were crafted with such precision that they felt like an art form, and the dessert? Wow—there are no words to describe how incredible it was.
This restaurant is a must-visit. I will definitely be recommending What If of Hershey to everyone I know!
Feel free to use this as is or adjust it to your liking!
First time here and won’t be our last. Our waitress Brooke was amazing. She gave great recommendations and when she recommended the spiced pear martini she said “it’s like fall in a glass” and she wasn’t wrong. Our food was amazing and I can not wait to return!
We stopped in for the first time on Saturday evening. We were a little freaked out that the restaurant was attached to a Howard Johnson. Once we got downstairs we were happily surprised by the atmosphere. The restaurant was decorated nicely for the holidays and it felt very welcoming. We ordered the crab dip bowl appetizer, the steak and crab special and chicken parmesan. Everything was very good but I felt that the crab dip and the steak needed more seasoning. The food wasn't bad but it was lacking flavor. The steak definitely needed some salt and pepper. The chicken parm was phenomenal tho. We will definitely be back in the future.
Great atmosphere in the restaurant, though is in a weird location, underneath the checking area of a Howard Johnson Motel. You walk right between the desk and the room where the do the free continental breakfast and take stairs down to the basement. But once there, it is a unique experience. A little pricey, but worth every penny. The food was amazing, lamb cooked to perfection with mashed potatoes and green beans that were fresh and cooked perfectly. We shared a pan fried scallops appetizer, though way too pricey for the quantity you got,, was cooked perfectly they melted in your mouth with a raspberry sauce drizzled on the plate. Never would of thought raspberry with scallops, but it was the perfect contrast on the palette.The staff couldn't have been more gracious. And the dining room itself was perfect for anything from a romantic dinner, celebration, or just a food lover wanting a nice quiet spot. I will definitely go there regularly
We went to “What If” on a whim after a visit to Hershey Park- we travelled from NY. After we located it, we were incredibly pleased by the atmosphere and ambiance. Our waitress Brooke was incredibly kind and attentive. As a group of 4, we ordered different entrees and drinks and were very pleased with our choices. The Lobster Ravioli and Baked Seafood earned rave reviews as we all gave one another’s entrees a little taste. The drinks were fabulous and their Pinot Noir was amazing. Brooke certainly deserves an honorable mention for her kindness and consideration. For a Tuesday evening, it was considerably busy and everyone seemed to be having a lovely time and enjoying themselves. If ever we’re in the area again, we would most definitely come in for another round of amazing food and a great time. The four of us highly recommend this establishment. Make sure you visit if you’re in the area, you won’t be disappointed.
We inquired about the name of the restaurant and it was based on this beautiful poem which Brooke was kind enough to bring out for us.
Celebrated our 43rd Anniversary here. Our Server was absolutely delightful, the atmosphere is cozy, however, (we did smell mold as this restaurant is below grade) the food was delectable!!! The Owner is very sweet and friendly, too!
New years eve, called for take out...too busy for them to do it due to the large rush of people with Reservations. This place held us a last min table! The decorations were beautifully done ✔️ ???? the food is always amazing, drinks are strong and delicious, servers are very friendly and quick service! They go the extra mile to make sure you are happy and comfortable, thank you for that!! I will definitely be back with friends and family !
I don’t know how this restaurant is not rated 5 stars, must be professional food critics giving out these reviews. I have visit this place multiple times and I can highly recommend them. The server was very knowledgeable and attentive and let me and my fiancé know the chefs specials for the day. I went with the filet mignon with the vegetable medley of the day and mashed pot. The filet was so soft to cut I honestly could’ve shredded it with my fork! My fiancé order the baked seafood and he loved it! The chef and sous chef are extremely talented and I give my props to the restaurant owner. This business is ran very professionally and I will most definitely be coming back.
Quick Facts About What If... of Hershey
Today
Opening Hours
| Sunday | Closed |
|---|---|
| Monday | 02:00 AM - 10:00 PM |
| Tuesday | 02:00 AM - 10:00 PM |
| Wednesday | 02:00 AM - 10:00 PM |
| Thursday | 02:00 AM - 10:00 PM |
| Friday | 02:00 AM - 10:00 PM |
| Saturday | 02:00 AM - 10:00 PM |
How to go there