Hero image

Webb's Captain's Table Restaurant

+1 716-753-3960
115 W Lake Rd, Mayville, NY 14757 United States of America
Open Today:

Amenities

Service options
  • Outdoor seating
  • Takeout
  • Dine-in
Highlights
  • Fireplace
Accessibility
  • Wheelchair accessible entrance
Offerings
  • Alcohol
  • Beer
  • Cocktails
  • Coffee
  • Comfort food
  • Small plates
  • Wine
Dining options
  • Lunch
  • Dinner
  • Dessert
  • Seating
Planning
  • Accepts reservations
Payments
  • Debit cards
  • NFC mobile payments
  • Credit cards
Children
  • High chairs
  • Kids' menu
Parking
  • Free parking lot
  • Parking

Best WLM Reviews

Nice large restaurant. We sat upstairs outside so we could have a view of Lake Chautauqua. Arrived at 4 pm when they opened on a Friday evening, so there wasn't a wait. We started by ordering drinks. A Margarita ($12.00) and a Blueberry Remedy ($10.50), both of which were good but very small. Barely 8 oz of liquid by time the ice was added to the glass. The variety of rolls came out warm and were delicious. My husband and I both ordered the Chicken Mediterranean, which was presented very well and was delicious. Lastly, their dinners do not include salads, so we ordered house salads in addition to our dinner for a $13.90 up charge for 2. Our waitress was friendly and good at her job. If we are back in the area, we will probably eat there again for the location.
From my parents who had dinner there this evening-- We came for our 33rd anniversary dinner tonight, thinking we were going to receive 5 star dining based on the prices, however, we were WRONG.
We had the lamb special and the meat was extremely over cooked and the mashed potatoes were the worst I have ever eaten in my life. The best way to describe the potatoes are a consistency comparable to PASTE!
The biscuits were hard and tasted like they over used baking soda in the recipe.
The Beef tenderloin was ordered as medium rare and it came out to us as medium well. I can make a better tenderloin at home in my Traeger than these people did tonight. At least I use a temperature gage to indicate the temp for medium rare and don't over cook my steaks.
The baked potato was brown on the inside. Which is an indicator that it was either over cooked or leftover from the day prior and reheated for the meal.
The house salad dressing should have been left out on the range. It did NOT taste like any type of ranch dressing I have eaten in my life. I'm pretty sure it was just mayonnaise with some light seasonings.
The strawberry shortcake was nothing to be desired. It hardly had any strawberries or whipped crème. You are better off going to Dairy Queen for a dessert.
Service was extremely slow and it wasn't packed. We had to wait 15 minutes to receive a glass of water! What are these cooks and servers doing?
Don't bother wasting your money at a restaurant like this. You are better off going into Jamestown or Erie to eat at a chain restaurant like Red Lobster or Olive Garden.
Beautiful building, the food was okay for the price. The beef on wick was delicious.. however the service is poor. Waiting staff was as unfriendly as you can get. Hand you something and take off immediately, never asked if we needed anything or how our plates were. We had to go find someone for another beverage. A smile goes a long way and there were none to be found! .
They are in the middle of remodeling. Nice people, and it's going to be beautiful when they are finished. You could see that they are working on it, but you don't see all of the equipment, and we didn't hear anything.
If you like noise when you sleep you will need to play something on your phone. It's very quiet!
They do have a pool, and it looked very nice and clean. We didn't have time to use it. Just a one night stay for us.
Our waitress Julie was the best from start to finish. Food was good. Love the seasonal decor and oil lamps on the table.
Stopped here for lunch on a quiet Wednesday afternoon since we were in the area. Besides my husband and I , there appeared to be 2 other tables. The interior is nice enough and our waitress was friendly enough. My husband got a burger and I got the grilled chicken salad. We split the shrimp cocktail and bruschetta appetizers. The meals were fine , if unremarkable. What keeps this from being a 3.5 star or even 4 star was the slow as molasses service. I know some people enjoy a leisurely lunch, but the slow service was painful as could be. She did refill my husband's soda once but never asked if we wanted the check. We had to make it extremely obvious we were done but even then there was no sense of urgency. We were there over an hour and a half and for two people who are always on the go, it was really too much time. Also, the prices were not, in my opinion, commiserate with the food quality, although that's a matter of personal opinion and open to debate.
*** FRAUD .*** This restaurant has gone out of business and the property is listed for sale. A gift card we purchased only 9 months ago is now unusable - along with many others’ who share the same problem. The restaurant owners have not responded to complaints filed with the credit card company nor the State Attorney General. I was told that the owners have left New York State. The restaurant website remains active - with no mention of being closed - and continues to sell electronic gift cards despite the business being closed! These people have knowingly absconded with money spent in good faith and continue to sell gift cards via their website.
Went for Lunch with my wife and mother, sat on the balcony and it was a great view and awesome food and service. Joe provided superior service. I will be returning again.

Quick Facts About Webb's Captain's Table Restaurant



Today

Opening Hours

How to go there

Location