Anthony's Pizza Info
Amenities
Service options
-
Delivery
-
Takeout
-
Dine-in
Highlights
-
Fast service
Popular for
-
Lunch
-
Dinner
-
Solo dining
Accessibility
-
Wheelchair accessible entrance
-
Wheelchair accessible parking lot
-
Wheelchair accessible restroom
-
Wheelchair accessible seating
Offerings
-
Alcohol
-
Beer
-
Comfort food
-
Quick bite
-
Small plates
Dining options
-
Lunch
-
Dinner
-
Dessert
-
Seating
Amenities
-
Restroom
Atmosphere
-
Casual
-
Cozy
Crowd
-
Groups
-
Tourists
Planning
Payments
-
Credit cards
-
Debit cards
-
NFC mobile payments
Children
-
Good for kids
-
High chairs
-
Kids' menu
Parking
-
Free parking lot
-
Free street parking
Best WLM Reviews
First time here and my dad had been telling me how great it was. Prices were very reasonable. We got a medium meatlover's pizza, Garlic parmesan wings and strawberry cheesecake. The pizza was loaded with toppings and high quality as there was no grease. The sauce had a great flavor and the dough was the perfect texture. The wings were HUGE and perfectly cooked. And if you have room for dessert, definitely get some cheesecake!
Really good food and Max went above and beyond considering we came in just before closing. We never felt rushed and had an enjoyable experience.
Who ever is readying this and is from New York? Or a relocate? Who is looking for THE BEST New York style pizza and calzones? As someone that moved back from Florida from Manhattan, THIS IS THE ONLY TRUE NEW YORK PIZZA that I have found to date that , when I close my eyes after taking a bite of my pizza, puts me right back in Manhattan taking a bite of Joe’s pizza. Yes, it reminds me of Joe’s Pizza on Broadway that we all went to eat at after a play. Today I ordered a Calzone, I normally get a cheese pizza and a half dozen of garlic rolls. This are, seriously the BEST and FRESH garlic knots.
All i am saying is, GIVE THIS PLACE A CHANCE! Look at all the positive results. You will taste and smell Manhattan when you eat in this place. The young man behind the scenes is always making sure he does the best that he can, so dedicated. I believe he is the owners son. I think they have other locations not sure, only care about this one. LOL
No I have nothing to do with the owners, I have no clue who they are, I am a pizza freak that’s all. I use to eat Pizza seven days a week. Now I’m down to four or five days a week. Ive tried all the pizza places around here”Stavropol in Grand Island and eustis location is awesome as week, Greek pizza and then FREAKING BEST GREEK SALADS YOU WILL EVER HAVE) The place downtown eustis that claims to have NEW YORK PIZZA that uses a Conveyor oven to cook their “NEW YORK STYLE PIZZA” ummmmmmmmm, yeah about that?! I visited about 30 to 40 pizza Restaurants in New York to New Jersey WOULD NEVER CLAIM TO BE COOKING NEW YORK PIZZA AND USE A Conveyor Oven. The owner does not know what customer service is, very unfortunate. The pizza is really, really good but WAY over priced for this area. What she does not know is her own guest are scared of her due to the way she treats people. Very sad but I hope one day she realized how she speaks and treats her guest. If she does one day, I’m be her first Customer that left due to her mannerisms towards her guest.
Let me know if this helped you. Trying to increase the number of my reviews considering I eat out 5 times a week.
Take care, JW
Excellent food. April our waitress was great as well. This will be my new spot.
I should have reviewed these guys the first time I tried their NY pepperoni pizza, best I've ever had! Anyway, I eat there almost every week, it is ALWAYS FIRST RATE. Anyway, I love all their other stuff too, and today I wanted a calzone delivered. And I live in a crazy complicated complex, DJ delivered it within 4 min of it being expected,and called for clarification when things weren't clear.
Great job, consistently wonderful food no matter what you order, for a really reasonable price.
Came to the restaurant at 7:32 and was told they couple only accommodate to go orders because they closed in “20 minutes.” I recommend them changing their hours if they are that concerned about closing the dining room prior to 8PM. We were excited to bring our family of five for dinner.
Always great service and delicious pizza. My kids love this pizza place.
I have been there twice, once for lunch and once for dinner. Mybl lunch experience was really good. I ordered the stromboli. The service and food was awesome. I came 2nd time and it was around 830 at night I did not realize they closed at 9 I ordered a pizza for dine-in. Once I was seated I was told dining was not an option anymore and had to take it to go. The pizza was good but not amazing. To be clear my parents owned 3 Italian restaurants growing up and I am Italian on both sides of my family so I am a little picky about Italian food.
Excellent pizza, but no tea or juice! Sure, many are fine with soda (or a nice cold beer), but I gave up soda quite a while back (can't drink it now for medical reasons anyway) and having water with pizza is not exactly pleasant. They have a tea machine, but I was told that they haven't served it for a couple years and the owner says it doesn't sell every day. Maybe try stocking some individual bottles of it? Again, the pizza is good, even better if you could get the Bianca by the slice... but you can't (my second disappointment). The caeser salad was decent, but very awkward to add dressing due to the small plate it is served on. Too small of a plate for the salad. I'll order a full pizza for takeout next time as eating there just didn't do it for me. Service was great, so I shouldn't blame the staff for business decisions.
Quick Facts About Anthony's Pizza
Today
Opening Hours
| Sunday | 02:00 AM - 09:00 PM |
|---|---|
| Monday | 02:00 AM - 02:00 AM |
| Tuesday | 02:00 AM - 02:00 AM |
| Wednesday | 02:00 AM - 08:00 PM |
| Thursday | 02:00 AM - 09:00 PM |
| Friday | 02:00 AM - 09:00 PM |
| Saturday | 02:00 AM - 09:00 PM |
How to go there